:: Re: [DNG] vdev status update: perfo…
Top Page
Delete this message
Reply to this message
Author: James Powell
Date:  
To: shraptor, dng
Subject: Re: [DNG] vdev status update: performance, bugfixes, and udev events
Having this news brings us many steps closer to a full udev replacement.

One step closer to shattering the stranglehold of udev forever. I just wish I could be at the Linux Conference when vdev goes RTM and completely shatters the hopes and dreams of systemd. I'd be, or try to be, the first to give Jude a standing ovation, and if Lennart tries his usual interruptions, yell out, "Excuse me, Lennart, sir, but you do us one favor? Sit down and shut up! We came to hear Jude, not some poop throwing monkey!"

No offense to poop throwing monkeys.

-Jim
________________________________
From: shraptor<mailto:shraptor@bahnhof.se>
Sent: ‎7/‎7/‎2015 10:41 AM
To: dng@???<mailto:dng@lists.dyne.org>
Subject: Re: [DNG] vdev status update: performance, bugfixes, and udev events

On 2015-07-07 17:45, Jude Nelson wrote:
> Hey everyone,
>
> I have the latest news for vdev:
>
> * [EXPERIMENTAL] Vdevd now has actions and helpers that will cause it
> to generate and propagate device events to libudev-compat clients.
> Libudev-compat clients should receive hotplug events as they would
> have with libudev, and they should be able to enumerate devices.
> This means that it should be possible now to run X11 with vdevd and
> libudev-compat, without needing an xorg.conf. To do so, you'll need
> to symlink vdev's /dev/metadata/udev to /run/udev.


CONFIRMED WORKING - a great milestone Jude, F***ing good work!

Both keyboard and mouse working without Xorg.conf :-)

When inserting flash memory sticks they get autodetected and device
nodes created :-)

Question This is working without a value for
/proc/sys/kernel/hotplug so it is not used and
only for udev???


>
> * Hardware database access performance has been significantly
> improved, and made more accurate (i.e. it should now match all
> prefixes against the device modalias, not just the longest one). By
> "significant", I mean by an order of magnitude.
>
> * As an optimization, vdevd can now run specially-crafted helper
> scripts as "daemonlets." Instead of fork()/exec()'ing a shell for
> each action, vdevd will instead fork() an action's command once and
> feed it a sequence of device requests, encoded as a list of
> environment variables. When running as a daemonlet, the command will
> be expected to run a loop that will parse the request from vdevd, call
> the command's main body of code, and report back the "exit" status.
> The heavyweight scripts (i.e. the ones that benefit from this) have
> all been turned into daemonlets in this round of commits. This leads
> to around 25% performance improvement (on average) for each command.
>
> * vdevd now benchmarks its actions, and writes performance information
> to its logfile at the end of coldplug processing. Just to give a
> reference frame: vdevd currently takes about 9 seconds to
> cold-process all of my laptop's hardware (i.e. it's slower than udev,
> but not that much slower).
>
> * libvdev is no longer a build target. Its code will instead be
> statically linked to vdevd and vdevfs. This is to make installation
> and deployment easier. There's no real loss to doing so--the library
> isn't that big in the first place, and the only programs that will
> ever use it are vdevd and vdevfs (note that libvdev is not at all
> related to libudev).
>
> * Bugfixes:
> -- the pre-seed script that runs before coldplug device processing can
> now create device nodes, and signal to vdevd to run the associated
> helper scripts anyway.
> -- the pre-seed script will select the first free loop device (with
> losetup -f) for the hardware database.
> -- [NEEDS CONFIRMATION] the ifname.sh script should select the correct
> config file now. I'm still chasing down a "Device or resource busy"
> bug in renaming interface names, so please keep your eye out for it.
> -- [NEEDS CONFIRMATION] the disk.sh helper should now generate
> /dev/disk for USB disks.
>
> Thanks to everyone who helped me test vdevd so far!
> -Jude
> _______________________________________________
> Dng mailing list
> Dng@???
> https://mailinglists.dyne.org/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/dng

_______________________________________________
Dng mailing list
Dng@???
https://mailinglists.dyne.org/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/dng