On 2021-08-28 16:37, jakolineplayer@??? wrote:
> I sent this bug report to the dedicated email but didn't receive the
> automated response, so I'm sending a duplication here.
>
> Package: rfkill
> Version: 2.33.1
> Severity: critical
>
> Problem:
> Devuan 3.1 beowulf installer uses rfkill to BLOCK wifi networking by
> default on a fresh minimal installation, by minimal I mean that only
> 'standard system utilities' and 'print server' is chosen in tasksel,
> this happens in the absence of package rfkill itself which is needed
> to UNBLOCK networking. No internet plus no way to enable internet
> makes the system of no use or non-beneficial for most users.
>
> Steps to reproduce:
> 1- Download and burn devuan_beowulf_3.1.1_amd64_netinstall.iso
> 2- boot you cd/usb and start the installer with firmware enabled
> 3- When asked about networking use wifi and proceed
> 4- When tasksel dialogue appears untick every thing and only leave
> 'standard system utilities' and 'print server' checked, we want a
> minimal installation without any desktops
> 5- After installation is finished remove the cd/usb and boot into your
> newly installed system
> 6- Login as root
> 7- Try to put your wifi interface up. You'll receive error
> 'SIOCSIFFLAGS: Operation not possible due to RF-kill'
> 8- Try using rfkill to unlock networking via command 'rfkill unblock
> wifi; rfkill unblock all'. Bash will tell you 'rfkill: command not
> found'
>
> Expected behavior:
> 1- Networking should not be blocked by default, not by using rfkill
> nor any other method.
>
> 2- The wireless interface should be brought up by default on first
> boot because it was used during the installation, and my chosen wifi
> hotspot should also be running by default, most distros do that, they
> preserve the wifi configuration that was used during the installation
> (SSID & password), I think Debian too does it. Please investigate if
> it can be done in Devuan as well, for user convenience.
>
> Note:
> Strangely enough, as seen in steps to reproduce (step number 8), the
> tool that was used to soft-kill networking (rfkill) is actually absent
> from the system, meaning that it was only present during the
> installation and was used by the installer before shutdown and after
> all the work was done.
>
> Note #2:
> When using an Ethernet cable instead of wifi during installation this
> problem DID NOT occur.
>
> Please see what you can do about this severe issue , maybe it's
> inherited from Debian, I don't know as I've never used wifi to install
> Debian before, I always go with the iso option that does not include
> non-free firmware, hence always using ethernet to install Debian,
> either way, please Investigate.
>

Yes, you do know. As per
https://dev1galaxy.org/viewtopic.php?pid=31172#p31172 you have already
been advised that this is the behavior of the Debian installer under the
installation choices that you made so the bug report should be filed
with Debian.

golinux