Skribent: Rowland Penny Dato: Til: dng Emne: Re: [DNG] Request for comments - training room
On Sun, 2 Dec 2018 10:07:23 +0000
Simon Hobson <linux@???> wrote:
> Rowland Penny <rpenny@???> wrote:
>
> >> Indeed, but this scenario is for a fixed setup where the users (28
> >> of them) are setup once and then there is no further user
> >> maintenance going forward. In such a scenario, there's little
> >> point in going for the complexity of setting up AD - as you say, a
> >> one-off setup of the users in Samba. The clients could potentially
> >> be configured to auto-login to the desktop (or training system) on
> >> boot so the users don't even need to know about users. Easy for
> >> users, no security.
> >
> > Been there, done that, but with that many computers it becomes a
> > struggle, the users want to use different computers and cannot
> > because they are not set up on that computer, believe me, if you
> > are setting something up of this size, a domain is the way to go.
>
> Sorry, I think you missed the point of the scenario I was talking
> about. This one is where the users don't have their own login - they
> all use just the same login, so can sit down at any machine and use
> the single login that's configured on the machine, and there's no
> need for any user management on each machine other than setting up
> the one user login. That might be appropriate if the training system
> handles user management etc.
>
> Otherwise, I agree with you.
>
If you could set up such a scenario, then yes, your way could be used,
but there was a mention of a server. If you have a server, you usually
get files saved and read, so how do you differentiate between user
'fred' from computer18 and 'fred' from computer23 ?