July 26, 2017 8:59 AM, "Jaromil" <jaromil@???> wrote:

> On Wed, 26 Jul 2017, nextime@??? wrote:
>
>> Exactly, when i wrote releasebot the first thing i care about was
>> permissions, and using project and group permissions on gitlab you
>> can have granular per project or by group permissions.
>
> Depending from gitlab instead of git for what we are doing is a road
> to desaster. I urge you to understand that, we have analysed for long
> time the situation and reached the conclusion we need to minimise the
> dependency and limit it to a git repository, independent from the UI
> running on it.

The thing that maybe isn't clear is that we don't depend on gitlab: we depend on everything has a group/user permission system and can be linked by http requests, as releasebot has an abstraction layer for that.


> About Scorsh, I think you are missing to note it is covered by tests
> (unlikely anything else one may gotouch around in scripts on a
> production system) and is written in a way that can be extended in
> future for instance attaching new functions and triggers.

Yes, but it's an unuseful addition that add complecity for no purpose