:: Re: [DNG] Mini init script written …
Góra strony
Delete this message
Reply to this message
Autor: Didier Kryn
Data:  
Dla: dng
Temat: Re: [DNG] Mini init script written in Perl boots.
Le 18/06/2016 10:41, Arnt Gulbrandsen a écrit :
> Didier Kryn writes:
>>     Did you try it? The documentation of Bash is not clear. I think 
>> it says that a bash script can only wait the processes it has 
>> launched. Does it mean it maintains a list of them, or is it just the 
>> consequence of the fact that any process but pid1 cannot adopt 
>> others' children? In the last case, why the need to repeat it.

>
> Processes cannot adopt children; the kernel foists processes on pid 1
> without asking either pid 1 or any other process.

     Sure but it does not need to be mentionned in the bash manual. In 
addition, the bash manual does not mention it is generic. This what 
raised my interrogation.

>
> Bash's source code is very, very large compared to zsh, which offers
> roughly the same functionality. The extra lines of code code have to
> do something, so it's entirely possible that bash tries to duplicate
> the kernel's list of children. Or not. I'm not going to look, it
> doesn't seem a useful thing to do.


     I bet it is simpler to experiment than to dig into the source of 
whatever-sh.


     In general, I don't buy so easily the arguments about the 
complexity of going through an interpreter (wether zsh or perl). I'm not 
sure these interpreters are much more complex than the C compiler. They 
are very well tested and you want them on your machine anyway. I'm not 
making an argument in favour of interpreters, just trying to ponder 
arguments against.


     Didier